An aged pine cabin dining corner with an oval birch table, two wooden chairs, and closed windows overlooking pine trunks and exposed rock.

The Beam Under Lake Vermilion Has One Winter Left. That's Why Big Bay Is Getting Ten Detectors.

Fermilab plans to set forty ten-ton concrete anchors and ten steel tanks on the floor of Big Bay, northeast of Ely Island, before the lake freezes. Each tank holds neutrino detectors. The crew is Veit and Co., the same contractor doing the water and sewer work at Tower Harbor, and it is working from McKinley Park Campground. As of the Timberjay's October 29 report, the campground had a barge made of more than 20 connected sections and a crane being assembled to carry it all across more than three miles of open water.

The experiment is in Big Bay because of the Soudan Mine, a few miles from town. Fermilab aimed a neutrino beam at the mine two decades ago, the beam still passes under the lake, and it shuts off for good early next year. That deadline is why the crew is trying to get the tanks into the water before ice-in.

A Beam Aimed at the 27th Level

Fermilab finished its NuMI beamline, short for Neutrinos at the Main Injector, in 2005. Its main job was to feed MINOS, an experiment whose far detector sat underground at Soudan. The detector was on the 27th level of the mine, the same mine that now runs public tours out of Soudan Underground Mine State Park. An extended phase called MINOS+ started in 2013, and Fermilab reports that MINOS and MINOS+ finished their runs on June 29, 2016. That spring, the Duluth News Tribune reported that both big Soudan experiments were winding down and that smaller ones would continue in the mine.

The detector went away, but the beam kept running. It also serves other experiments, including NOvA farther north, and on its way to Soudan it passes through both Lake Superior and Lake Vermilion. That path is what the new project is built around. The University of Minnesota Duluth's September 1 announcement describes the Experimental Neutrino Detector, or END, as a test of whether natural lake water can be used to spot neutrinos from a laboratory beam and tell them apart from cosmic rays. Large natural bodies of water and ice have been used to observe neutrinos from space, but according to UMD, nobody has yet detected laboratory-made neutrinos that way.

The Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency is sponsoring END, working with the Department of Energy's Office of Science, Fermilab and Brookhaven National Laboratory. The research team comes from UMD, the University of Wisconsin, Drexel University and the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution.

Why the Calendar Is So Tight

UMD says the experiment has to prove itself before the beamline is decommissioned in 2027. At an October Fermilab webinar for area residents, physicist Jen Raaf made that more specific. She said the experiment will end in February 2027, when the NuMI beam is turned off permanently. Fermilab's own April 2026 accelerator schedule projected NuMI running from October 1, 2026 to March 1, 2027. Either way, the beam runs for one more winter, and the detectors have to be sitting in its path while it does.

Three things set the schedule.

  1. The beam's last months. Data collection has to happen between now and early 2027. UMD's release puts the whole testing window at October 2026 through about April 2027.
  2. Ice. "Once the ice arrives, we're all done," a Veit operations supervisor at McKinley Park Campground told the Timberjay. In late October, the paper reported an extended forecast of mild weather that should keep the lake open at least through mid-November.
  3. Camping season. Fermilab spokesperson Rae Moss said campground managers asked for the work to wait until after the main camping season. That request, together with DNR recommendations, shaped both the fall installation and the plan for removal.

The Timberjay's October 22 webinar coverage said installation could start the following week and finish by late November if the lake stays ice-free. A week later, the anchors were starting to arrive at the campground. The detectors had not been shipped to Soudan yet because Fermilab was waiting on final approvals, according to spokesperson Tracy Marc.

What Is Actually Going Onto the Lakebed

The Lake Superior half of the project uses a different technology. Off Two Harbors, a Woods Hole research vessel will set frames of glass sensor spheres on the lakebed. Those sensors only work at night, because daylight reaching the bottom drowns out the faint flashes they look for. The Big Bay detectors don't have that limit. Here is what UMD and the Timberjay describe:

  • Ten tanks. Each is about 8 feet tall and 21 feet long and holds two flat-panel detectors. Fermilab calls them muon underwater monitors, or MUMs.
  • Plastic scintillator panels inside. Particles from a neutrino hitting the surrounding water pass through the panels and make them flash. The tanks are sealed against light, so they can run 24 hours a day.
  • Four ten-ton concrete anchors per tank, forty in total. The crew lowers them first, then attaches the tanks, which sit under about 20 feet of water.
  • A barge with a rectangular opening in the middle. Anchors and tanks are lowered through the opening.
  • A cable to shore. It runs along the lakebed to a metal shed at a cabin site on the north side of Ely Island. Fermilab says the whole setup draws about 3,000 watts, roughly two handheld hair dryers. The tanks make no sound, and the only noisy thing in the shed is a window air conditioner.

The location already changed once. Once it was clear that the sediment at the original site couldn't hold the anchors, Fermilab moved the deployment several hundred yards east. Picking a launch point took some trial and error too. Veit first looked at Hoodoo Point, where Fermilab judged the water too shallow, and DNR Parks and Trails turned down a request to use the new Moccasin Point public access. That is how McKinley Park Campground became the staging area for both installation and removal.

In September, the Timberjay reported that Fermilab planned to mark the site with buoys and had been in touch with the St. Louis County Sheriff about it. UMD's position is that the project should not interfere with daily life, local businesses or recreation on the lake.

What Neighbors Asked, and What Fermilab Answered

About a dozen area residents joined the October webinar. The Timberjay reported that water quality and the fishery were their main concerns. The questions focused on the lake bottom. Lake Vermilion is listed as impaired for mercury, and much of the methylmercury sits in the sediment, so residents asked what happens when forty heavy anchors are set down and later pulled back up. Bill Pellico, who oversees much of the project's engineering for Fermilab, said the anchors will be lowered and raised very slowly to keep sediment disturbance to a minimum. Fermilab officials said they would follow up on what the core samples from the site showed.

Removal timing was the other topic. UMD's September release said the detectors would come out in late spring or early summer 2027, depending on lake conditions. At the webinar, Fermilab officials gave late summer or fall 2027 instead, based on the DNR's recommendations and the campground's request to work outside peak camping season. Raaf said the experiment itself wraps up in February 2027, when the beam shuts off.

Moss told the webinar that area communities have long partnered with Fermilab on neutrino and high-energy physics research. In practical terms, this winter Big Bay holds the last experiment on a beam that has pointed at the Soudan Mine since 2005. The tanks are scheduled to come out in 2027, after the beam is off for good.

Where Things Stood Heading Into November

At the end of October, the barge and crane were being assembled at McKinley Park Campground and anchors were arriving. The detectors themselves were waiting on final approvals before they could ship to Soudan, and Fermilab was aiming to finish by late November, before ice-in. If you're out on the east end of the lake over the next couple of weeks, the barge crossing from the campground toward Ely Island is this project. The Timberjay has followed it since late summer and is the best place to check for updates. For more on what's going on around town between now and freeze-up, see our Tower neighborhood page and our look at the Mesabi Trail's first mile out of Tower.

If you own shoreline on Big Bay or near Ely Island and want to talk through what a project like this means for your place on the lake, Taylor Glynn and The Snyder Team know this end of Vermilion well. Reach out anytime, and we'll help make your cabin dream a reality.

Contact Us

Let's Connect! Provide your contact information below and I'll be sure to be in touch quickly!